Exporing Key Lime Pie: Where to Find the Best Slice in Marathon

Welcome to Gulfview Getaways, your gateway to luxury and charm in Marathon, Florida! In this post, we’re diving into the delicious world of Key Lime Pie and uncovering the best places to indulge in this iconic dessert in Marathon. So, grab a fork and get ready to satisfy your sweet tooth!

Get ready for a sweet and tangy adventure as we dive into the fascinating history of Key Lime Pie!

In the late 1800s, Key Lime Pie was born in the Florida Keys. This iconic dessert owes its existence to the pioneers who settled in the Keys, primarily Bahamian and Cuban immigrants, who brought with them their culinary traditions and a passion for innovation.

The story begins with the Key lime (Citrus aurantifolia), a small, yellow-green citrus fruit native to the Caribbean and Central America. Key limes were abundant in the Keys, making them a staple ingredient in many local recipes. The Key lime’s tartness and unique flavor profile were the perfect starting point for a new dessert.

In the early 1900s, Key lime pie began to take shape. Cooks and homemakers in the Keys experimented with key lime juice, combining it with sweetened condensed milk, egg yolks, and a graham cracker crust. The result was a creamy, tangy, and utterly addictive dessert that quickly gained popularity among locals and visitors alike.

The Key lime pie’s fame grew rapidly, thanks in part to the 1930s’ growing tourist industry in the Florida Keys. As people flocked to the islands to escape the mainland’s sweltering heat, they discovered this refreshing dessert that perfectly captured the essence of the tropical paradise. Restaurants and cafes began serving Key lime pie as a staple dessert, further cementing its place in the hearts (and taste buds) of Floridians and visitors alike.

Fast-forward to today, and Key lime pie has become an iconic symbol of Florida’s culinary heritage. You can find it on menus from Miami to Key West, each iteration showcasing its own unique twist on this beloved classic.

As you prepare to indulge in Key lime pie at some of Marathon’s best spots, remember that you’re experiencing a piece of history. You’re savoring a dessert that has been perfected over generations, infused with the spirit of innovation, community, and tropical paradise.

Where to Find the Best Slice:

Now, the million-dollar question – where can you find the best Key Lime Pie in Marathon? Here are some top spots that you definitely don’t want to miss:

• The Island Fish Company: 12648 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050. Indulge in a slice of Key Lime Pie at this waterfront restaurant and enjoy stunning views of the Gulf while satisfying your sweet cravings. This pie is is made with high-quality ingredients and has a generous serving size. Guests describe this pie as a tangy and creamy dessert with a perfectly balanced flavor profile. The key lime juice provides a bright and citrusy taste, while the sweetened condensed milk adds richness and sweetness. The graham cracker crust provides a crunchy base for the filling
• Paradise Flavors: 9601 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL, 33050.  This authentic, made-from-scratch recipe combines the perfect balance of tangy key lime juice with a hint of sweetness, all wrapped up in a flaky and buttery crust. The result is a pie that’s both refreshing and rich, with a consistency that’s creamy yet firm. One of the most balanced and beloved key lime pie’s in Marathon.
• Burdine’s Waterfront: 1200 Oceanview Ave, Marathon, FL 33050. Their fried key lime pie is popular among locals and visitors alike, and many people rave about. It resembles a chimichanga, with a cool key lime filling wrapped in a tortilla, fried until crisp, and topped with cinnamon sugar. If your looking for a unique spin on this classic dessert its definitely worth a try!
• Fish Tales Market & Eatery: 11711 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050.  What stands out most is the creamy, tangy filling made with fresh key lime juice and a touch of sweetness, all nestled in a graham cracker crust that adds a delightful crunch. Locals rave about the pie’s vibrant flavor and smooth texture, making it the go-to destination for a taste of the Keys’ iconic des
• Keys Fisheries: 3502 Gulfview Ave, Marathon, FL 33050.  This pie is rich, velvety filling made with a generous helping a fresh key lime juice and a touch of sweetness, all baked into a homemade graham cracker crust that adds the perfect satisfying crunch. The combination of bold flavors and textures has earned the Keys Fisheries many accolades.
• Herbie’s Bar & Chowder House: 6350 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050. Herbie’s has been a part of the Keys dining scene since the 1940’s making it the oldest continually operated restaurant in Marathon. Their Key Lime Pie is made with fresh Key lime juice, sweetened condensed milk, and a graham cracker crust, baked to perfection and topped with a dollop of whipped cream. But what sets Herbie’s apart is their unique twist – they add a hint of caramelized sugar to the filling, giving the pie a rich and velvety texture. The result is a slice of pie that’s both tangy and sweet, with a satisfying crunch from the graham cracker crust.
• Sweet Savannah’s Bake Shop & Ice Cream Café: 8919 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050. This beloved bakery and cafe serves a renown key lime pie made with fresh squeezed key lime juice, a scratch-made graham cracker crust, and a super creamy filling. Their attention to detail and consistent commitment to quality have earned them rave reviews and a reputation as one of the best places to get key lime pie in the Florida Keys.
• The Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House: 3660 Overseas Hwy, Marathon, FL 33050.  Treat yourself to a slice of Key Lime Pie after a savory meal at this upscale restaurant in Marathon. Their pie is a rich and creamy dessert with a perfectly balanced flavor profile. It’s topped with whipped cream and toasted coconut flakes, which adds an extra layer of flavor and texture.

Don’t forget to pair your Key Lime Pie with a refreshing Mojito or a scoop of vanilla ice cream for the ultimate indulgence! Our favorite toppings include homemade whipped cream, fresh berries, mint, slivered almonds, or toasted coconut.

Summary:

• Key Lime Pie originated in the Florida Keys and is a must-try dessert in Marathon.
• Top spots to find the best Key Lime Pie in Marathon include The Island Fish Company, Sweet Savannah’s, and The Florida Keys Steak and Lobster House.
• Pair your Key Lime Pie with a cocktail or ice cream for a truly delightful experience.

Ready to embark on a culinary adventure in Marathon? Book your stay with Gulfview Getaways and explore the best dining and cuisine options in this tropical paradise! Visit our website here to check availability or give us a call at (239) 777-2083 for any inquiries. Bon appétit!